During California’s recent drought, residents faced difficult decisions as water resources became scarcer. Many took steps to conserve, and for some, this meant draining their backyard pools. While these actions were intended to conserve precious water, they came with unexpected consequences. For homeowners, the drought didn’t just affect water usage—it also raised questions about how conservation choices might impact other aspects of their lives.
1. When Conservation Efforts Backfire
Marilyn and Joe Smith believed that draining their pool was a logical way to conserve water during California’s extended drought. With their grandchildren grown and no longer visiting as often, the Smiths decided that maintaining a large, water-hungry pool was unnecessary. But their decision had an unexpected consequence: AAA canceled their homeowners’ insurance. The Smiths were stunned. They had hoped to contribute to water-saving efforts. Instead, they found themselves scrambling for new coverage and questioning the fairness of insurance practices.
2. Drone Surveillance Pinpoints “Neglect”
The Smiths’ case took another twist when they learned that AAA had used drone technology to survey their property, Images captured from above showed the empty pool, which the insurer classified as a liability. Though the Smiths saw draining the pool as an act of responsibility, AAA viewed the empty space as “deferred maintenance.” This lack of maintenance, the company argued, increased the risk to their property. For Marilyn and Joe, it was a wake-up call on the growing role of surveillance in insurance decisions and how even well-intentioned choices can be misinterpreted.
3. From an Unused Pool to a Greenhouse
Rather than leaving their drained pool idle, the Smiths had transformed it into a mini greenhouse, growing tomatoes and lettuce in the California sun. They enjoyed the added benefits of fresh produce and continued water savings, finding a new purpose for the space. However, AAA’s policy decision was unchanged, and the Smiths were forced to seek alternative insurance providers. Their story quickly became a cautionary tale on how innovation at home can clash with traditional insurance practices, especially as technology increases scrutiny on homeowners.
4. Another Neighbor Falls Victim
The Smiths weren’t the only ones facing unexpected policy cancellations. Neighbor CJ Sveen also lost his insurance due to what AAA described as “clutter” in his front yard. Sveen, who uses his yard as a workspace, found it troubling that the company’s decision was based on images they refused to share or discuss. For Sveen, the experience was both invasive and confusing, lacking any clear guidelines on what might constitute a cancellation. Without any opportunity to address the “clutter” in question, he, too, had to look for new coverage.
5. Spiking Insurance Withdrawals
Sveen and the Smiths are part of a larger trend in California, where homeowners face increasing difficulty in securing insurance. Major companies like State Farm and Allstate have stopped issuing new policies, citing wildfire risks, high construction costs, and difficult conditions in the reinsurance market. This has left many Californians scrambling to find coverage. With drone-based inspections and stricter guidelines now in play, the challenges of keeping a home insured in the Golden State are becoming a new reality for many.
6. An Unprecedented Drought
California’s most recent drought spanned several years, marking one of the longest and most intense dry periods in the state’s recorded history. Low rainfall and record-high temperatures pushed water resources to their limits, forcing cities to implement restrictions and prompting residents to rethink their daily water usage. This prolonged water crisis drove many, like the Smiths, to look for ways to conserve—draining pools, cutting back on outdoor watering, and reducing water waste at home. Though the drought has now eased, its impact still lingers in changed habitats and heightened concerns.
7. Struggles for Wildlife
The effects of California’s drought weren’t limited to humans—wild animals struggled as rivers, lakes, and other natural water sources dried up, shrinking available habitats and forcing some species to adapt to urban environments. Bears, coyotes, and other animals were spotted more frequently in towns, foraging for food and water. This shift placed extra pressure on local ecosystems and disrupted the natural balance. Conservationists faced a growing challenge, working to ensure that these animals could survive without harming or being harmed by human communities.
8. Transforming California’s Flora
California’s plant life also faced significant changes due to years of water scarcity. Native plants struggled, often unable to compete with invasive species that could thrive in drier conditions. This altered landscape not only impacted local ecosystems but also created added fire hazards, as many of these invasive plants—such as eucalyptus trees—are highly flammable. With drier, more combustible plant life spreading across the state, fire risks are a constant concern, affecting homeowners, communities, and wildlife in equal measures.
9. Draining Pools: A Double-Edged Solution
During the drought, emptying swimming pools became a strategy for water conservation, especially for those who rarely used their pools. Pools require thousands of gallons of water annually, not only to fill but also to counter evaporation, making them a costly asset in dry regions. But as the Smiths discovered, a drained pool can be seen as neglect and result in unexpected insurance complications. California residents now find themselves weighing the pros and cons of having a pool in an era when environmental factors heavily influence homeownership.
10. Insurers Act to Minimize Natural Disaster Risks
Insurance companies nationwide are reassessing policies in states prone to natural disasters, especially California and Florida. Drones, AI, and other tech tools enable insurers to identify properties with potential risks more precisely than ever. However, these advancements can mean that customers are penalized for minor issues without a chance to address them. Many Californians are now forced to adhere to strict standards to avoid policy cancellation, a reality affecting both new and long-time homeowners alike.
11. A Short Supply of Lower Quality Water
As drought conditions depleted California’s lakes and rivers, water quality issues emerged. Pollutants became more concentrated, leading to the growth of toxic algal blooms that harmed wildlife and made some water bodies unsafe. The lack of clean water has had a lasting impact, creating both environmental and health concerns. Even as the drought eased off, communities continue to contend with these aftereffects, striving to balance water conservation with ecosystem health.
12. Everyday Water-Saving Tips
Californians know that small changes can make a big difference when it comes to water conservation. Installing low-flow showerheads, choosing drought-tolerant landscaping, and fixing household leaks are some of the most accessible ways to cut water usage. Many cities also encourage rainwater harvesting, offering rebates to those who install rain barrels or other collection systems. By integrating these practices, homeowners can save water efficiently and contribute to long-term sustainability without major lifestyle changes.
13. Smarter Pool Management
Emptying a pool isn’t the only option for those seeking to save water. Pool covers can significantly reduce evaporation, helping to preserve water levels with minimal maintenance. Lowering the pool’s water level by a few inches is another way to conserve without sacrificing usability. Additionally, switching to saltwater or low-chlorine treatments can further reduce maintenance needs. With these adjustments, pool owners can avoid the risks that come with total drainage while still managing water usage.
14. The Benefits of Greywater Recycling
For households aiming to reduce their environmental footprint, greywater systems are a practical solution. These systems collect water from sinks, showers, and laundry machines, redirecting it for irrigation in gardens or landscaping. Greywater systems allow Californians to recycle everyday household water—a valuable adaptation that supports conservation efforts even beyond drought conditions. They offer a sustainable alternative to traditional water use, promoting efficient resource management across communities.
15. Climate Change’s Impact on Insurance
With climate risks growing, insurers are increasingly cautious about offering policies in vulnerable areas. California homeowners face a shifting landscape where properties require diligent upkeep and risk assessments to maintain coverage. Insurance companies may continue or increase the use of high-tech assessments to determine risk factors, pushing homeowners to stay vigilant about property maintenance. For Californians, this means new routines that align with both environmental changes and insurance industry demands.
Sources:
- ABC7 Los Angeles: California couple loses homeowners’ insurance after draining their swimming pool to save water
- California Department of Water Resources: Drought
- SwimmingPool.com: How to Prepare Your Swimming Pool for Severe Weather – Drought
Stay connected with us for more stories like this! Follow us to get the latest updates or hit the Follow button at the top of this article, and let us know what you think by leaving your feedback below. We’d love to hear from you!
